CHENNAI: If ‘grace mark’ medical doctors perform surgical procedures, sufferers will have to recover only with the grace of god. So pronouncing, the Madras high court docket has refused to direct Pondicherry University to grant grace marks to a medical pupil.
Justice S Vaidyanathan, ridiculing grace marks being awarded in medical classes, noticed that voters can be taken for a ride if such practices had been allowed to be persevered. If a person who is studying ophthalmology is allowed to clear his papers with grace marks, the sufferers will have to regain eyesight only with the grace of god, he stated.
Justice Vaidyanathan made the commentary whilst dismissing a plea moved by S Bharathi, a 3rd 12 months MBBS pupil of Sri Manakula Vinayagar Medical College and Hospital, Puducherry seeking direction to the Pondicherry University to grant grace marks to him.
The petitioner stated she had cleared all papers in first and second years of the route. The 3rd 12 months consisted of three topics - group medication, ENT, and ophthalmology. She appeared for checks in June 2016 and cleared two papers except for ophthalmology.
She appeared for the ophthalmology subject in November 2017 and failed again.
Though she secured minimum required score in the subject, she was once declared fail given that she did not fulfil the extra minimum requirement of 40% in the college theory exam.
She added that she has secured 29 marks in theory paper instead of required 32 and hence lacked simply 3 marks to be declared pass. Pointing out that upto five grace marks can also be granted to students as per college rules, she made a representation to the college to grant her 3 marks. Since the authorities failed to respond, she approached the high court docket.
Justice S Vaidyanathan, ridiculing grace marks being awarded in medical classes, noticed that voters can be taken for a ride if such practices had been allowed to be persevered. If a person who is studying ophthalmology is allowed to clear his papers with grace marks, the sufferers will have to regain eyesight only with the grace of god, he stated.
Justice Vaidyanathan made the commentary whilst dismissing a plea moved by S Bharathi, a 3rd 12 months MBBS pupil of Sri Manakula Vinayagar Medical College and Hospital, Puducherry seeking direction to the Pondicherry University to grant grace marks to him.
The petitioner stated she had cleared all papers in first and second years of the route. The 3rd 12 months consisted of three topics - group medication, ENT, and ophthalmology. She appeared for checks in June 2016 and cleared two papers except for ophthalmology.
She appeared for the ophthalmology subject in November 2017 and failed again.
Though she secured minimum required score in the subject, she was once declared fail given that she did not fulfil the extra minimum requirement of 40% in the college theory exam.
She added that she has secured 29 marks in theory paper instead of required 32 and hence lacked simply 3 marks to be declared pass. Pointing out that upto five grace marks can also be granted to students as per college rules, she made a representation to the college to grant her 3 marks. Since the authorities failed to respond, she approached the high court docket.
Madras HC rejects medico’s plea for grace marks
![Madras HC rejects medico’s plea for grace marks]()
Reviewed by Kailash
on
May 01, 2018
Rating:
