MUMBAI: The police by slapping a fantastic on a Good Samaritan who offered a boost to other folks in need has left citizens speechless and legal professionals confused at a "clearly wrong application of law".
Lawyers on Monday mentioned it may be time for lawmakers to even revamp the statute e book to remove lifeless laws.
“The applications of certain laws like this one have grow to be redundant with social norms changing,” mentioned recommend Mihir Gheewala. “In instances where pooling of vehicles is inspired by government itself as it has grow to be a requirement of recent residing, one of these slim assemble of the section is uncalled for.“
The section in query is Section 66(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act. The police had slammed it on the hapless motorist. It says, “No owner of a motor automobile shall use or permit the use of the automobile as a transport automobile in any public position whether or not or no longer such automobile is in fact wearing any passengers or items save in keeping with the conditions of a permit granted or countersigned by a Regional or State Transport Authority or any prescribed authority authorising him the use of the automobile in that position within the means during which the automobile is being used:”
The regulation calls for a permit for cars for use for ferrying other folks. The State issues a “a stage carriage permit” which subject to conditions authorises the use of the automobile as a contract carriage.”
Another lawyer Ashwin Thool says, "Mechanical utility of the regulation steadily reasons serious injustice to blameless citizens. Section 66 (1) bars the use of a automobile for a business and or business purpose without a legitimate permit for such business and or business task. In fact, Section 192 particularly exempts activities carried out by excellent samaritans in occasions of distress. To automatically slap a fantastic on a citizen who volunteered help to troubled citizens reflects very poorly on the police and is counterproductive as it disuades citizens from serving to every others in instances of distress.”
- ALSO READ: Traffic cop who challaned excellent samaritan transferred
Lawyers on Monday mentioned it may be time for lawmakers to even revamp the statute e book to remove lifeless laws.
- ALSO READ: Bengaluru won't ever do what Mumbai did — challan a do-gooder
“The applications of certain laws like this one have grow to be redundant with social norms changing,” mentioned recommend Mihir Gheewala. “In instances where pooling of vehicles is inspired by government itself as it has grow to be a requirement of recent residing, one of these slim assemble of the section is uncalled for.“
The section in query is Section 66(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act. The police had slammed it on the hapless motorist. It says, “No owner of a motor automobile shall use or permit the use of the automobile as a transport automobile in any public position whether or not or no longer such automobile is in fact wearing any passengers or items save in keeping with the conditions of a permit granted or countersigned by a Regional or State Transport Authority or any prescribed authority authorising him the use of the automobile in that position within the means during which the automobile is being used:”
The regulation calls for a permit for cars for use for ferrying other folks. The State issues a “a stage carriage permit” which subject to conditions authorises the use of the automobile as a contract carriage.”
Another lawyer Ashwin Thool says, "Mechanical utility of the regulation steadily reasons serious injustice to blameless citizens. Section 66 (1) bars the use of a automobile for a business and or business purpose without a legitimate permit for such business and or business task. In fact, Section 192 particularly exempts activities carried out by excellent samaritans in occasions of distress. To automatically slap a fantastic on a citizen who volunteered help to troubled citizens reflects very poorly on the police and is counterproductive as it disuades citizens from serving to every others in instances of distress.”
Mumbai: Law outdated, says lawyers after cops slap fine on Good Samaritan
![Mumbai: Law outdated, says lawyers after cops slap fine on Good Samaritan]()
Reviewed by Kailash
on
June 26, 2018
Rating:
