MUMBAI: A different court on Wednesday convicted gangster Chhota Rajan and 7 others for homicide of journalist J Dey in November 2011. The court acquitted journalist Jigna Vora and Paulson Joseph, who were a SIM card supplier.
Rajan was once held guilty of conspiracy and homicide and under Maharashtra Control of Organised Crime Act (MCOCA). He attended the court via a video conferencing facility from Delhi.
The court acquitted Deepak Sisodia who had supplied carriages of homicide price however discovered guilty of criminal conspiracy.
The prosecutor Pradeep Gharat didn’t search demise sentence for the convicted. He left it to the discretion of the court conserving in thoughts the seriousness of the crime because it was once an attack on the fourth pillar of democracy. The contractors were hired for execution of conspiracy and the victim had a mother and a completely dependent sister. Dey’s mother already died and the court will have to consider grant of repayment for sister.
The court will pronounce the quantum of sentence through 5 pm
Dey (51) was once gunned down in Powai, allegedly on the behest of don Chhota Rajan.
Besides Rajan, who was once extradited to India in December 2015, 10 others confronted trial in the case. Journalist Jigna Vora, one of the most accused, was once suspected of having passed on Dey’s information to the gangster.
Special public prosecutor Pradeep Gharat stated 155 witnesses deposed, of which seven were declared adversarial after they did not support the prosecution’s case. Key witnesses, Gharat stated, were journalists to whom Rajan spoke after the homicide. Gharat termed them “additional judicial confessions” and stated Rajan had expressed to a journalist his feel sorry about concerning the homicide. “The confessions of 3 accused—Arun Dake, Deepak Sisodia and Joseph Paulson—sooner than the DCP were also necessary pieces of proof,” he added.
Referring to the technical proof, Gharat stated call information information showed the assailants had kept an eye fixed on Dey close to his space and were on the homicide spot when he was once shot. “Scientific reviews showed the bullets recovered from Dey’s frame and shells recovered from the spot matched with the weapon seized from a chawl in Amboli. Accused Satish Kalia guided the police to the chawl,” he stated. Another necessary witness, the prosecutor stated, was once analyst Edward Burns from a US forensic laboratory, who deposed via video-conferencing. Burns stated the bike that the assailants came on was once same as the only discovered through police officers all through the course of investigation.
With recognize to Rajan, Gharat stated his voice samples taken in Tihar prison, where he's lodged, matched with the recordings of conversations he had with a journalist after the homicide. During the arguments that concluded on Tuesday, Rajan’s defence advocates Anshuman Sinha and Hasnain Kazi picked holes in the manner wherein the voice samples were accumulated and the testimony of the skilled who deposed on the samples. They stated that the skilled’s file says the voice is “most likely” that of Rajan’s.
The advocates placed on file a number of judgements on procedures for voice popularity. They argued that one cannot merely depend on a witness’s observation that the person on the other finish of the decision was once indeed Rajan. He stated the prosecution will have to have given that witness a number of voice samples, including Rajan’s, and asked him/her to spot. Pointing out that psychology plays a task, the advocates stated previous to receiving the calls, the police held a press convention on June 27, 2011 during which Rajan was once named the primary accused. The defence stated this will have created a bias.
A timeline of the occasions:
MAY 22, 2011
Rajan allegedly calls up aide Satish Kalya and asks him to make preparations to hold out a success on Dey. Kalya allegedly forms a 7-member workforce, asks them to organize vehicles, and will get a .32-bore revolver and 25 cartridges from Deepak Sisodia in Nainital.
JUNE 6-Nine
The gang allegedly conducts a reconnaissance of the Powai place of abode.
JUNE 11
The gang allegedly follows Dey on motorbikes and an SUV as he runs errands close to his place of abode. Kalya allegedly pumps five bullets into Dey’s back.
JULY 1-NOV 16
A couple of TV channels claim Rajan known as them up wherein he purportedly admits to getting Dey killed. In those conversations, Rajan is quoted as pronouncing that Dey was once involved with Dawood and the ISI, and that a girl journalist “instigated” him (Rajan). He is additional quoted as pronouncing that Dey “had crossed his limit”.
DEC 11
Police document 3,055-page price sheet for homicide, conspiracy and carrying palms and explosives in opposition to the accused with the exception of Vora. In a subsequent price sheet, the police stated Vora had supplied Dey’s cope with and vehicle registration details to Rajan.
2012
JULY
Vora will get bail on the grounds that she had a kid to look after as a unmarried father or mother, and that her detention was once now not required since the investigation was once over.
2015
APRIL 25
Vinod Asrani alias Vinod Chembur, who was once allegedly the primary co-conspirator and financer of the hit, dies of natural reasons. He had allegedly “pointed out” Dey to Kalya and his workforce a few days sooner than the homicide.
JUNE
Special MCOCA court frames fees in opposition to 10, including Vora.
OCT
Rajan arrested in Bali and deported to India.
2016
SEPT
MCOCA court frames fees in opposition to Rajan for homicide and criminal conspiracy.
2017
MARCH 23
A witness identifies Rajan’s voice from a conversation between the gangster and a real estate dealer. In the clip, Rajan purportedly makes inferences to Dey with out naming him; also names Vora
2018
JAN 30
Rajan denies calling any of the witnesses after the killing or that he took Dey’s licence plate number from Vora.
APRIL 2
Defence claims the method of collection of Rajan’s voice samples erroneous, asks that the tapes now not be admissible as proof
APRIL four
Court fixes May 2 as judgment day
Rajan was once held guilty of conspiracy and homicide and under Maharashtra Control of Organised Crime Act (MCOCA). He attended the court via a video conferencing facility from Delhi.
The court acquitted Deepak Sisodia who had supplied carriages of homicide price however discovered guilty of criminal conspiracy.
The prosecutor Pradeep Gharat didn’t search demise sentence for the convicted. He left it to the discretion of the court conserving in thoughts the seriousness of the crime because it was once an attack on the fourth pillar of democracy. The contractors were hired for execution of conspiracy and the victim had a mother and a completely dependent sister. Dey’s mother already died and the court will have to consider grant of repayment for sister.
The court will pronounce the quantum of sentence through 5 pm
Dey (51) was once gunned down in Powai, allegedly on the behest of don Chhota Rajan.
Besides Rajan, who was once extradited to India in December 2015, 10 others confronted trial in the case. Journalist Jigna Vora, one of the most accused, was once suspected of having passed on Dey’s information to the gangster.
Special public prosecutor Pradeep Gharat stated 155 witnesses deposed, of which seven were declared adversarial after they did not support the prosecution’s case. Key witnesses, Gharat stated, were journalists to whom Rajan spoke after the homicide. Gharat termed them “additional judicial confessions” and stated Rajan had expressed to a journalist his feel sorry about concerning the homicide. “The confessions of 3 accused—Arun Dake, Deepak Sisodia and Joseph Paulson—sooner than the DCP were also necessary pieces of proof,” he added.
Referring to the technical proof, Gharat stated call information information showed the assailants had kept an eye fixed on Dey close to his space and were on the homicide spot when he was once shot. “Scientific reviews showed the bullets recovered from Dey’s frame and shells recovered from the spot matched with the weapon seized from a chawl in Amboli. Accused Satish Kalia guided the police to the chawl,” he stated. Another necessary witness, the prosecutor stated, was once analyst Edward Burns from a US forensic laboratory, who deposed via video-conferencing. Burns stated the bike that the assailants came on was once same as the only discovered through police officers all through the course of investigation.
With recognize to Rajan, Gharat stated his voice samples taken in Tihar prison, where he's lodged, matched with the recordings of conversations he had with a journalist after the homicide. During the arguments that concluded on Tuesday, Rajan’s defence advocates Anshuman Sinha and Hasnain Kazi picked holes in the manner wherein the voice samples were accumulated and the testimony of the skilled who deposed on the samples. They stated that the skilled’s file says the voice is “most likely” that of Rajan’s.
The advocates placed on file a number of judgements on procedures for voice popularity. They argued that one cannot merely depend on a witness’s observation that the person on the other finish of the decision was once indeed Rajan. He stated the prosecution will have to have given that witness a number of voice samples, including Rajan’s, and asked him/her to spot. Pointing out that psychology plays a task, the advocates stated previous to receiving the calls, the police held a press convention on June 27, 2011 during which Rajan was once named the primary accused. The defence stated this will have created a bias.
A timeline of the occasions:
MAY 22, 2011
Rajan allegedly calls up aide Satish Kalya and asks him to make preparations to hold out a success on Dey. Kalya allegedly forms a 7-member workforce, asks them to organize vehicles, and will get a .32-bore revolver and 25 cartridges from Deepak Sisodia in Nainital.
JUNE 6-Nine
The gang allegedly conducts a reconnaissance of the Powai place of abode.
JUNE 11
The gang allegedly follows Dey on motorbikes and an SUV as he runs errands close to his place of abode. Kalya allegedly pumps five bullets into Dey’s back.
JULY 1-NOV 16
A couple of TV channels claim Rajan known as them up wherein he purportedly admits to getting Dey killed. In those conversations, Rajan is quoted as pronouncing that Dey was once involved with Dawood and the ISI, and that a girl journalist “instigated” him (Rajan). He is additional quoted as pronouncing that Dey “had crossed his limit”.
DEC 11
Police document 3,055-page price sheet for homicide, conspiracy and carrying palms and explosives in opposition to the accused with the exception of Vora. In a subsequent price sheet, the police stated Vora had supplied Dey’s cope with and vehicle registration details to Rajan.
2012
JULY
Vora will get bail on the grounds that she had a kid to look after as a unmarried father or mother, and that her detention was once now not required since the investigation was once over.
2015
APRIL 25
Vinod Asrani alias Vinod Chembur, who was once allegedly the primary co-conspirator and financer of the hit, dies of natural reasons. He had allegedly “pointed out” Dey to Kalya and his workforce a few days sooner than the homicide.
JUNE
Special MCOCA court frames fees in opposition to 10, including Vora.
OCT
Rajan arrested in Bali and deported to India.
2016
SEPT
MCOCA court frames fees in opposition to Rajan for homicide and criminal conspiracy.
2017
MARCH 23
A witness identifies Rajan’s voice from a conversation between the gangster and a real estate dealer. In the clip, Rajan purportedly makes inferences to Dey with out naming him; also names Vora
2018
JAN 30
Rajan denies calling any of the witnesses after the killing or that he took Dey’s licence plate number from Vora.
APRIL 2
Defence claims the method of collection of Rajan’s voice samples erroneous, asks that the tapes now not be admissible as proof
APRIL four
Court fixes May 2 as judgment day
J Dey verdict: All you need to know
![J Dey verdict: All you need to know]()
Reviewed by Kailash
on
May 02, 2018
Rating:
